Go to the homepage for the Sylva Herald and Ruralite

Commissioners endorse action to reverse recent EPA decision

By Rose Hooper
and Lynn Hotaling


The Jackson County Board of Commissioners unanimously passed a resolution urging N.C. Attorney General Roy Cooper to join other states in filing a Petition for Review against the recent decision by the Environmental Protection Agency to weaken the Clean Air Act's New Source Review "Routine Maintenance" provision.

Offered by the Canary Coalition and passed Tuesday (Nov. 18), the resolution also urges the entire North Carolina Congressional delegation to co-sponsor legislation to reverse the EPA decision.

The New Source Review calls for plants to install modern technology to control pollution if planned upgrades go beyond routine maintenance.

However, the new rules, scheduled to take effect next month, would allow plant operators to spend up to 20 percent of the value of their plants on improvements without having to go through environmental reviews.

This means that in five years a factory or power plant could be completely rebuilt under the guise of "routine maintenance."

In passing the resolution Jackson County follows the example set by the towns of Sylva and Chapel Hill as the first to pass the resolution.

"In 2001, when we asked the commissioners to pass a resolution supporting the Clean Smokestacks Act, they did, making Jackson County the first in the state to do so. Others joined and the act – one of the strongest ever – was passed. We are asking Jackson County to take a stand again," said Avram Friedman, chairman of the Canary Coalition.

"I support this 100 percent," said commissioner Joe Cowan. "Western North Carolina is getting the brunt of air pollution from other states. Meanwhile the EPA is gutting the Clean Air Act. We are going to pay for it is asthma cases."

Votes on similar resolutions are pending in Buncombe and Mecklenburg counties, the cities of Durham, Salisbury and Asheville, Friedman said.

"There has been no indication, to date, from our attorney general's office about his intentions regarding this matter," said Friedman, "although state officials from at least 13 other states have joined together to challenge the EPA's decision in federal court."

Friedman said he believes the EPA's action is illegal because the agency has disregarded the legislative intent of the NSR provision of the Clean Air Act, which is that all grandfathered power plants and factories would eventually be brought up to modern emission control standards as the plants were modernized and expanded.

The North Carolina Sustainable Energy Association and Environmental Defense and Carolinas Clean Air Coalition are working on this campaign with the Canary Coalition.

Back to Archive: 11/20/03.


Go to the Homepage Contact Subscribe Advertising Classifieds Archives Obituaries Submissions Deadlines About The Sylva Herald