Go to the homepage for the Sylva Herald and Ruralite

Anderson pleads not guilty in father's death

By Rose Hooper

A former Jackson County prisoner entered a not guilty plea Dec. 18 in Jefferson County Circuit Court in Wisconsin.

Derek Anderson, 34, pleaded not guilty to first-degree intentional homicide in the death of his father 55-year-old father, Allen Krnak, whose remains were found in the Moses Creek section of Caney Fork in December 1999.

Jurisdiction in this case has shifted from Jackson County to Jefferson County.

When he was arrested in February 2001 at a Milwaukee halfway house, Anderson fought extradition to North Carolina where the Jackson County Sheriff's Office had charged him with first-degree murder.

Anderson appealed his extradition to North Carolina on numerous fronts, both state and federal, but was transported to Jackson County in December 2002 and remained here until Sept. 4.

North Carolina dropped murder charges against Anderson Aug. 19 after Wisconsin District Attorney David Wambach filed similar charges in that state.

"After long and careful consideration I decided that there is insufficient evidence that the murder of Allen Krnak occurred in North Carolina and, as a result, North Carolina does not have jurisdiction of this case," local District Attorney Mike Bonfoey said in August.

Anderson did not fight extradition back to Jefferson County and on Sept. 4 detectives from the Jefferson County Sheriff's Office picked up Anderson at the Jackson County Jail and returned him to Wisconsin.

Unlike North Carolina, Wisconsin does not have a death penalty.

Allen Krnak, his wife, Donna, 52, younger son, Thomas, 21, and family dog, Hunter, all disappeared in Wisconsin in early July 1998. They left their home in Helenville, Wisc., July 2 of that year on the way to their log cabin in Colma, Wisc., but they never arrived. Their empty truck was found on a public hunting ground near Reedsburg, Wisc.

Derek Anderson was living in Wisconsin at the time and was the last person seen with his father, mother and brother, Bonfoey said.

"This is a Wisconsin tragedy. It is suspected by Wisconsin authorities that foul play took place in Wisconsin.

All the suspicious circumstances indicating foul play occurred in Wisconsin. The witnesses are all from Wisconsin. The accused is from Wisconsin. The defendant is a Wisconsin resident and should be tried in Wisconsin," Bonfoey said.

Anderson changed his name from Andrew Krnak just days after his family disappeared. A 1994 graduate of Western Carolina University, he had lived on campus in Reynolds Dorm and off campus in Alpine Apartments in Cullowhee.

At the time of his indictment, Jackson County investigators said they had evidence placing Anderson most recently in Western North Carolina in 1998.

Moses Creek, where hunters found the remains of Allen Krnak's body, is approximately 10 miles from campus. Remains, presumed to be that of the family's cocker spaniel, were found near the body.

An autopsy revealed that Allen Krnak was killed by a blow to the left side of his face and head that broke his jaw in two places.

Anderson's mother and brother are still missing.

Jackson County Sheriff Jimmy Ashe has said he will cooperate fully with the Wisconsin authorities in Anderson's prosecution.

Anderson remains in the Jefferson County Jail in lieu of $3 million bail. Jefferson County Judge William Hue has ordered Anderson have no contact with any family member.

Back to Archive: 12/25/03.


Go to the Homepage Contact Subscribe Advertising Classifieds Archives Obituaries Submissions Deadlines About The Sylva Herald