Go to the homepage for the Sylva Herald and Ruralite

School officials dismiss suspended SMHS principal

By Lynn Hotaling


Nicholson

Citing "material and evidence presented in executive session," local school officials Sept. 4 dismissed veteran Smoky Mountain High School Principal Kenny Nicholson.

School board member Ken Henke, a former SMHS principal who served as assistant principal under Nicholson for six years at SMHS and several years at Fairview, moved to terminate Nicholson's employment. Henke's motion, approved unanimously, included the stipulation that Nicholson be barred from all school system property except the administrative offices on Hospital Road.

School Board Chairman James Roper, citing state personnel law, declined to elaborate on the reasons for Nicholson's dismissal.

Superintendent Mack McCary also declined comment.

"I can't comment on personnel matters," he said.

Board members' decision to ban Nicholson from school property was made "due to the nature of the charges that led to (Nicholson's) dismissal," McCary said Tuesday.

As written, board members have permanently barred Nicholson from school system property, except the Central Office, said Paul Holt, school board attorney. Should Nicholson wish to attend a specific school-related function, he could petition the school board for permission, Holt said.

In a statement Monday, Nicholson expressed disappointment and indicated a lawsuit may be forthcoming.
"I am very disappointed in the decision of the school board. I have not commented until this time in order to give an opportunity for this matter to be properly investigated and procedures followed to respond to the allegations," Nicholson said.

"I received my notice of dismissal from the Internet (This newspaper's Web site broke the news an hour after the school board's Sept. 4 decision.) prior to being formally advised by the superintendent of the board's actions. The superintendent had already informed me that I was to be dismissed based on his recommendation before I was ever provided a copy of the allegations.

"I requested a hearing with the board, but they declined. At this time the only recourse I have is to seek relief through the court so that this matter may be resolved in a public forum," Nicholson said.

McCary denied that he had told Nicholson he would be dismissed before Nicholson had seen the complaints against him.

"The only thing I told Mr. Nicholson when he was suspended with pay was that the investigation would determine what happened next," McCary said. "I did not inform him of my intention to recommend his dismissal until he had the opportunity to review the letters of complaint, meet with the investigative team, and meet with me."

Though school officials have consistently declined to reveal the cause of Nicholson's June 23 suspension, it is apparently based on complaints of sexual harassment made by a female administrator and at least two teachers.

SMHS Instructional Specialist Mary Anne Barker filed a July 21 incident report with the Jackson County Sheriff's Office, alleging that Nicholson kissed her against her will June 20.

According to the report, Barker said she would prefer school officials remove Nicholson or take appropriate action and that she "could not work in the same environment with him any longer."

Barker told investigating officer J.L. Hall that she had filed a written complaint with the Jackson County Board of Education and had received a reply from school officials indicating her report had been substantiated.
In the wake of Barker's criminal complaint, two female teachers confirmed they had made similar complaints to local school officials concerning Nicholson's behavior.

The two teachers, who asked their names not be used, said they had not pursued legal action or contacted law enforcement. One teacher indicated she had also received a reply from school officials saying her allegations had been substantiated.

A 1963 graduate of Sylva-Webster High, Nicholson was principal at Scotts Creek and Fairview elementary schools before moving to SMHS in 1994.

Back to Archive: 09/11/03.


Go to the Homepage Contact Subscribe Advertising Classifieds Archives Obituaries Submissions Deadlines About The Sylva Herald